This is what you have been waiting for, darlings, so here it is.
David and I first saw the revival of "Gypsy," with Audra McDonald and Company, on January 26, 2025. No one was out that day, so there were no understudies.
If you go back to my original post, readers, you will discover I was less than enchanted. As was David. After the Christmas week shutdown, when they had no understudies--at least, not one for Rose--we wondered what it would be like to see someone beside Audra in the role. Would it be better. Could it, possibly??????????????
Well, Fate came to our rescue, when we got to see "Gypsy" a second time, on Saturday, February 15, 2025, less than a month after having seen it the first time. Unfortunately, it was due to Audra McDonald having a death in her family, which I am sorry about, but it necessitated her being out for several performances. And the minute I heard the news, I wondered if there was an understudy, and how she might be in the role.
Thanks to our TIDF friends, we got a chance to see the understudy, Miss Tryphena Wade. Remember that name, darlings! And we were extra fortunate because the two actresses playing Baby and Dainty June, respectively, were also out. What a blessing all this turned out to be. It was like seeing an altogether different show!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
From the moment Miss Wade stormed down the aisle, Chowsie in hand, crying "Sing out, Louise," there was electricity in the house. And when she went into the opening of "Some People," Rose's first big song, David and I looked at one another and nodded our heads. Miss Wade may have been costumed and coiffed to look like Audra, but hers was a voice of a much different, and higher, caliber.
Meaning Wade had the vocal chops to handle the role, and demonstrated it, right up to her finishing act, with "Rose's Turn." There were still changes in the music of the latter that I did not agree with, and that were not needed for Miss Wade, but were obviously needed for Audra. I felt both sorry and disappointed for those who did not know in advance, like I did, that Audra would not be appearing. Many understandably asked for money back, to see Audra another time. I wish they had stayed. Because holding the two performances against one another, Wade's was unquestionably better. She stopped the show with the first act finale of "Everything's Coming Up Roses," singing it the way it should be sung, and then did it again with "Rose's Turn." Her vocal and breath control were perfect, unlike Audra, and she could easily have done this eight shows a week without losing her voice.
Ditto Marley Gomes and Sasha Hutchins, as the two Junes. Gomes, as Baby June, demonstrated a vibrancy that the original lacked, coming off more as Mama Rose's dream, than an annoying pre-Shirley Temple wannabe. As for Miss Hutchins, she brought meaning to the office scene, leading in to "If Momma Was Married," registering the right amount of bitterness and resentment, and in her own modulated voice, not the artificial child one, that was demonstrably better than the original, and on a par with Leigh Ann Larkin, back in the Patti Lupone production.
Danny Burstein continues to be the perfect Herbie, and Joy Woods is still the show's revelation as Louise/Gypsy. But there was something extra to this performance we saw. Having Wade as Rose gave the show a jolt, where everyone seemed to rise to her level, making for an altogether different, and better, "Gypsy" than the one we saw the first time.
Understudies only sub when called for. But, girls, my sources tell me that sometime in either July or August, Audra will be out on vacation. My advice to you is, if you want to see "Gypsy" at its best, wait till then, when Tryphena goes on. You will be so glad you did.
Interestingly, I have not heard a word about a cast recording of this show. With Audra such a name, and for Joy Woods' "Little Lamb," a recording would be worth the effort.
Darlings, in my over fifty years of theatergoing, this is the first time I have seen a show where the understudies are better than the originals.
Oh, George C. Wolfe's staging is still annoying--Rose eating dog food--why? --which she never did in other productions. The children's numbers are done on the cheap and so is just the single "ROSE" at the end of "Rose's Turn." Most embarrassing of all, at the first act finale, Wolfe has Rose clutching Louise in a headlock that comes off more as funny than tragic. Joy Woods is a better actress than that; like Celia Keenan- Bolger, she can convey a myriad of emotions just by standing and saying nothing, and such would have been better for this moment, as it would truly convey the horror the reluctant Louise knows she is in for.
As the original Rose, Ethel Merman once said, "The show is frozen--"Birds-Eye!!!!!!!!!!!!" So, there is not much that can be done now about Wolfe's staging, though how I would love a crack at it. "Gypsy," with its dramatic book and score will always remain a classic.
But who would have thought the understudies would have given this classic the stature it really deserves?????????????????
One last thing, darlings. I am still campaigning strongly for Chowsie and Caroline to get TONY nominations!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!