The Duke Theatre, that is, where the new musical, "Copperfield!" is playing, and David and I saw it, yesterday.
Don't be fooled by the exclamation point in the title. The show is not "Oliver!" It does not have a score to match it.
And this is not to be confused with the 1981 musical "Copperfield," which opened on April 16 at the ANTA (now the August Wilson) Theatre. It had Book, Music and Lyrics by Al Kasha and Joel Hirschhorn. Who went nowhere.
It had in the cast two Broadway stalwarts--George S. Irving and Mary Stout. And a young up and comer named Christian Slater, in a minor role.
The current musical is not any better, but it makes several serious mistakes.
Someone dumb here had the idea of going back to director John Doyle's gimmick of performing Sondheim musicals, with all the actos doubling as musicians. He did this, with no great effect, to "Company" and "Sweeney Todd." Thank God he never got to "Follies."
"Copperfield!" is performed like a live version of a Classic Comic Strip, but on speed. Many actors seem unsuited to their roles, especially Cathryn Wake as Dora. Meanwhile, Nancy O'Connor, early on should not be playing Em'ly; she looks a mature woman, and when she and young David (well played by Henry Wichter) it seems ill matched. And the accents vary. Bobby Conte cuts more a Byronic than Dickensian figure as the adult David, but his song "I Am Home," Dora's death scene, displays some talent. Act Two had moments that got to me--Dora's death, with its song, "Always The Pleasure Was Mine" and Agnes' proclamation of love, and her song, "If Only You Knew My Heart," probably the two best songs in the score, though as David said was I reacting to them genuinely or to my love for the characters in the book I love so much? I cannot answer that.
Everything--choreography, costumes and direction-- are merely serviceable Director Gabriel Barre was handed too large a task impossible to fulfill. My hopes were dashed.
Jeffrey Scharf wrote the Book, Music and Lyrics. Why is it one man thinks he can do this novel justice? He should have quit while has was ahead. Sure, he gets most of the story in, but what about dramtic nuance?
I still say when it comes to "David Copperfield," stick to the 1935 David O. Selznick, George Cukor Hollywood production. Oh my God, Maureen O'Sullivan as Dora!
Now, THAT is "David Copperfield!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"