I cannot say "Paranormal Activity" was my worst theater experience, but it certainly ranks among the top ten. I was expecting, hopefully, something imaginative and mildly entertaining. At worst, I thought it would be like a cheesy amusement park spook house ride. Well, I am telling you right now, those rides are better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Back in 2007, still riding on the found/filmed footage genre generated by "The Blair Witch Project" back in 1999, someone had the idea of making a film called "Paranormal Activity." It involved people living in a house and filming the mysterious things happening when they don't see them. All I can recall are doors opening by themselves and things moving mysteriously. That is how much of an impression the film made on me. The show in question made even less.
First of all, Chris Fisher and Abby May, who designed the illusions and lighting, had no idea what they were doing. When entering the August Wilson Theatre to take my seat, the lighting was so dim, I could not read my Playbill. Occasionally, the title, inscribed on a black floor length stage curtain in front of me would blink the titular words at the audience. Oh, boy, this is supposed to give us some big scare thrill????????????? Whom are they kidding???????????????
I really cannot fully blame Felix Barrett for his direction, because Levi Holloway's script is not much to work with. The two leads, whom I will get to, used so many f-words and other profanities that even David Mamet would blush!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Now, these actors, Cher Alvarez and Travis A. Knight. They are making their Broadway debuts, and I say enjoy it while it lasts. Because with this script, neither will get a second chance, nor will their careers go anywhere. They play a married couple, with the wife having some kind of anxiety and he trying to pacify her. Or is this really the case? Because, in Act Two, we get two people who have done misdeeds in their pasts and were never held accountable for them. Is this what is happening now? Does anybody care? I did not. Shannon Cochran as the mother livens things up, but Linda Lavin would have done it better. Except Linda would have turned this script down. And so would I!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Alvarez speaks with a pretentious accent, suggesting a desperate Juilliard auditionee. Knight may be nice to look at, but his hetero posturing is unbearable And can any of them read a line? I am telling you, producers could pull anyone from the street nightly to perform and would still get better results!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
There are supposedly 40 special effects in the show. With the dim lighting, I was barely able to see four of them; never mind the other 36. At an hour and forty five minutes this play belongs in the slush pile. It is a wonder how it got to Broadway. There is much more untapped, genuine talent out there.
Save for David and I, the audience ate it up! And the house was packed; maybe even sold out. Have we finally arrived at the dumbing down of Broadway? Are new audiences being sought to replace the old, those of us who go to the theater for something of entertainment and substance? Because if so, that audience will soon disappear, and like me, stay home with their Criterion Collections!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is as poor a start to the theater season as one can imagine! But who am I to talk? The show will probably run indefintely!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bur for those who REALLY care about theater, run for the hills, and avoid this trash altogether!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!