Now, don't get your knickers knotted, darlings. Having seen this show at least 40 times, I am not about to criticize it. But I would like to send this suggestion out into the blogosphere, in the hope someone may listen.
The other day I saw on YouTube a program about the 50th Anniversary of "A Chorus Line," held in the Bruno Walter Auditorium of The New York Public Library Of The Performing Arts. To be sure, I tried to get tickets to this event so I could be there in person, but I was not successful. Seeing it on YouTube at least gave me an idea of what went on, and I will have something to say about that.
On stage, representing the show were Original Cast members Baayork Lee, Donna McKechnie, Priscilla Lopez and Kelly Bishop. The moderator was this pretentious twit named Richard Jay Alexander, and my reaction to him is "What an A-hole!!!!!!!!!!!!!" He kept interrupting the ladies whom the audience would rather hear, and not his feelings, adulations or life changing experience as a result of this show. I mean, the guy has never danced a step, and he was so stupid he never got the facts right. Priscilla Lopez graciously corrected him about the title of the song "What I Did For Love," which he kept referring to as "Kiss Today Goodbye." Again, what an A-hole!!!!!!!!! I should have moderated the discussion because I know more about "A Chorus Line" than most people and certainly more than, again, this A-hole.
I have read all the books seen most of the footage and am most fascinated by the workshop process and the show in its earliest days at The Public. I did not see it until it moved uptown to the Shubert, where I saw it on October 25, 1975 with my father. I was just 20. It was a life changer for both of us. I knew the story about Cassie never getting the job, and how that upset people, how different people were chosen each night and no one knew who it would be, and Kelly Bishop as Sheila never got the job, which was a big surprise to me, because, next to Cassie, Sheila, despite her attitude, which I just love, darlings, was the most accomplished of the dancers. Kelly said she and Donna would exit the stage, and out of public hearing, she would say to her, "Let's go get a drink." I would love to go for a drink with Donna and Kelly.
All of this caught my eye. But it was something Kelly said that really blew me away. She said, in the early days at The Public, the show would end with those who got the job reacting--one reaching for the sky, as the lights came down slowly. Then three was complete darkness for seconds as the audience applauded, and then, like magic, the lights came up and the stage was empty, with only the white line showing.
Kelly said she wished the show had been done this way, and I agree. Because the show begins in blackness, and it should end in such. I understand why Bennett created the finale; the performers needed to be acknowledged, and it was a brilliant feat of staging. I love when they form a circle and the audience goes wild.
Nevertheless, at my age, I still feel I have a few more "Chorus Lines" in me. I would love to see one of the productions staged this way. It is so magical. Will I have to stage it myself to get this? I would love to take a crack at it, but I don't dance well enough to be a choreographer, so I would need one. Anyone interested? I wonder if Michael Bennett was alive what he would say to this?
Which brings us to the reason I am writing this post. The first show he did after "A Chorus Line" was "Ballroom," in 1978. Hopes were high, but he did not have another mega hit until "Dreamgirls," three years after that, in 1981. The cast included, among others, Dorothy Loudon, Vincent Gardenia, and veteran Marilyn Cooper. The ballroom dancing was magnificent, and hypnotically staged. This was a musical version of a TV Movie entitled "Queen Of The Stardust Ballroom," first aired on CBS on February 13, 1975. The script was by Jerone Kass and was based on information he discovered about his own mother after she had passed. In the movie, the lead character, Bea Asher, played by Maureen Stapletonn dies, which I disliked; it was like the writer having to punish the woman because she was having relations with a married man, albeit unhappily spoused. But what about him? He does not die? Why should Bea? But the networks were still prudish, so she had to be the one punished for allegedly committing adultery, though I am not sure the relationship was intimate; it was only at the Stardust Ballroom that the couple really shined.
When musicalized in 1978 as "Ballroom," Bennett staged and choreographed it, Alan and Marilyn Bergman did the lyrics, and Billy Goldenberg did the music. Jerome Kass, who wrote the TV movie, was brought in to do the show's book. Bea did not die in this version but has a sensational 11 o'clock number called "Fifty Percent," where she vocally decides that she would rather have what she and Al Rossi have at the Stardust than not have anything at all.
I saw the show, at the Majestic Theatre, shortly after it opened. I thought it was terrific except for one thing--the book scenes outside the ballroom got in the way of the show. I saw it on a Wednesday matinee, and as I was leaving the theater, who should I see standing in the back, talking to someone, but Michael Bennett. I so wanted to go up to him sand say that the show could be fixed if staged conceptually just inside the ballroom. I wonder what he would have said? I could have worked on it with him to fix it. Hell, if anyone decides to do "Ballroom," call me. I would love to make the show as it should be fully realized.
But back to "A Chorus Line." For me, it is arguably the most perfectly structured musical ever created, which is why I am so devoted to it. I wish some production would raise the perfection just a bar higher, by staging it the way Kelly referenced in its early days at The Public.
The things we do for love, darlings!
And the things I write about for love!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!