I am so sick of the redundancy in today's Broadway musicals. They all look, sound and feel the same. Color and glitz don't do it anymore; what I want is substance and originality. As Madame Armfeldt said in "A Little Night Music," "Where's discretion of the heart, where's passion in the art, where's craft?"
All are missing from "SMASH," which is expected to open at the Imperial Theatre, but who knows how long it will run? I bet it does not last until the TONY Awards. The show is about a show within a show making a musical comedy about Marilyn Monroe. Girls, are you confused? You should be.
"SMASH" has an array of talented artists floundering in a vehicle going nowhere. The recent opera of "Moby Dick" at the MET probably had more resonance.
What it has is a group of immensely talented artists trapped inside a black box of a stage, like the victims in "Attack Of The Puppet People." To be sure, for Theater Queens and insiders like me, I knew the references and who was based on whom. For instance, Brooks Ashmanskas, who plays Nigel, the director, is based on Walter Bobbie, whose career imploded when he drove "Chicago" understudy Jeff Loeffelholz to suicide. And Krysta Rodriguez, playing co-writer Tracy, is desperately trying to replicate either Priscilla Lopez or Laurie Beechman. Then there is the lead, Robyn Hurder, who spends the entire show replicating......Robyn Hurder. It is not entirely her fault, because the choreographer, Joshua Bergasse, replicates so many of the steps and moves from Michael Bennett's "A Chorus Line" I think Baayork Lee and John Breglio, who controls the Bennett estate, should march down to the Imperial, demanding the show be shut down, or overhauled.
All of this is not surprising, since Robyn Hurder is one of the best of our recent Cassies; I saw her do the role at the City Center Gala, several years back, and while no one is Donna McKechnie, she did a wonderful job. But so many of her moves, especially the arms, are reminiscent of that show, it is like she is doing "A Chorus Line" all over again, and the company is trying frantically to stage its opening number. If I WANT to see "A Chorus Line," I WILL see "A Chorus Line," not some hackneyed replication.
To think Susan Stroman, a choreographer herself, directed this mess. I can see this show nailing the head on her career coffin.
Oh, and of course the latest thing is using video and social media, which "SMASH" takes full advantage of. Maybe I am old fashioned, but I prefer moving music and dramatic substance to media gimmicks in a show which does not need them.
Back to nails driven into coffins. Shows like "SMASH" and others seen this season, are driving nails into the coffin of musical theater. I fear for its extinction.
Ernest Hemingway was an overrated writer, but he said it right, here--
"Ask not for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee."