How one views the current revival of "Gypsy," now at the Majestic Theatre depends on how well one does or does not know the show.
Those not knowing, or ever having seen "Gypsy," have a slight advantage, because, for them, this might turn out to be a satisfying theater experience.
But--
For those of us who know the show--gays and Theater Queens who, when young, lived our lives through this show until every word and move was in our bloodstream-- this revival will be something of a disappointment. While not as bad as Bernadette Peters in 2003, this "Gypsy" has the same problem--a fine supporting cast, but a leading lady not up to the vocal demands of the role.
Audra McDonald acts up a storm in this role; she plays it less like "King Lear," as this show has always been compared to, and more like "Medea," which is more appropriate. Unfortunately, her singing detracts from the power of the score. I knew she was in trouble when I heard her sing "Some People," but by the time she got to "Everything's Coming Up Roses," I was on the edge of my seat, not, unfortunately, because of the power of the delivery, but because I worried, she was not going to make it through the number. She barely had enough breath control to take on those lyrics, not to mention she cannot belt, so when she does, she goes up to head voice and loses vocal control and breath. Oh, and "Rose's Turn" she gasped her way through!!!!!!!!!!!! Like this--"Well someone tell me (Gasp!) when is it my turn? (Gasp!) don't I get a dream for myself (Gasp!!)" Are you kidding me? This is NOT the way to perform Rose in "Gypsy," and I do not accept it!
However--
The show is a familial tragedy and has always been viewed as about a mother who pushes her children to the success she always wanted, feeling she was better than anyone else, because she was, as she says, "born too soon, and started too late."
But, using Audra's vocal inadequacies to her favor "Gypsy' could be viewed through a more tragic prism--the woman who thought she had it all, but never did. In this context, it could work, but the question remains.
This is eight shows a week, darlings! Eight! Which makes me wonder how long can Audra hold her voice before it gives out?????????? Bernadette's revival did not run that long, so she saved her voice. But Audra worshippers are cramming to get into the Majestic, and that is not likely to stop soon. And then there is a possibility of Audra getting a seventh TONY Award? Can she hold out till then? More shall be revealed.
Now, Danny Burstein, perhaps the obvious choice, is a perfect Herbie. Joy Woods is a revelation aa the neglected Louise, and her rendition of "Little Lamb" is heartbreaking. Her transition to Gypsy Rose Lee is impressive, though she does go up on one line. When she comes out introducing herself in French, she omits the line "And that concludes my entire performance....in French!" "Gypsy" afficionados are sure to pick up on things like this. And the dressing room scene does not play as well as it should.
Why does Rose, in the opening, eat dog food? Why are the boys' first "Extra!" transposed down, when they do the second one perfectly? Why does Jordan Tyson as June let the audience see her disappointment at her mother on stage, but when time to verbalize she does a half assed job? No bitterness or resentment at all!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Why do some scenes play too fast, and others too slow? As for the new choreography, duh, who cares? And I prefer the strobe lights!!!!!!!!!! Why, when Rose clutches Louise to her at the end of the Act I finale, does it come off more as comic, than frightening?????????????? Why not more June and Baby June splits???????????? Why does Rose, who is from Seattle, speak in a Southern accent, and no one else does? Is she trying to play Rosa Parks????????
George C. Wolfe, what in the hell were you trying to do? Did you even know? You may be four months older than I, but I could stage a better "Gypsy," and in my next post I will prove it! Do you even know what the show is about??????????? Or couldn't you decide and try to make it both ways?????????? That is what it looks like and it does NOT work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! But the three strippers--Lesli Margherita, Lili Thomas, and Mylinda Hull, DO stop the show!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"Gypsy" deserves better. Those who want to see the glow of what this show really is, get on YouTube and watch the production with Patti LuPone and Laura Benanti.
Oh, and another thing. Chowsie and Caroline deserve their own curtain calls. And maybe TONY Awards.
One of the show's best lines is "You either have it/Or you've had it. With Audra McDonald at the helm, this "Gypsy" has had it.
As Leigh Ann Larkin's June said in Patti Lupone's revival, and so bitterly, "It....is.... a....terrible.... act!"
Which is how I feel about this "Gypsy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"